This was a valid response. I was quite popular with the ladies in middle school... and high school... and college... and basically throughout my entire life. One of the unfortunate side effects of being in the closet is that some people don't have exceptional gaydar, so they're blissfully unaware of the fact that their feminine charms are rather ineffective.
Here's the thing, I'm a nice guy. At least, I like to think I am. I can listen pretty well, and I try to be as loyal as people will let me be. I like to think that I'm the perfect GBF. I'll gossip, I'll watch the chick flicks, and get just as into them as any female. My problem is, when it comes to people I meet at church, I "forget" to mention the tiny little fact that I'm gay. It's not like it's something that you want to bring up in the first conversation with everyone you ever meet.
Friendly girl at church: "Hi, my name is Tabitha,"
Me: "Oh hi, I'm gay... Oh, I mean Shaun."
See, it just doesn't work. My problem, is I go to church to worship God. I'm not on the prowl to find a wife. I'm literally never on the prowl for a wife. Girl's sense this and get excited, because I'm not one of those guys. I don't feel the need to reference missionary leadership positions I held or use any other cheap ploy to attract a mate, because most LDS wards don't have a lot of gay men who are going to church and looking for a partner. It just doesn't work that way...
Anyway, all I'm trying to say is that sometimes I'm a jerk, and I accidentally lead people on. Sorry ladies.